Second opinion, free

Got a pitch?Send it. It comes back in red.

Before you sign anything based on someone's deck, valuation, or "financial plan" — send it over. Numbers checked against actual transactions, missing costs added, optimistic assumptions flagged. Takes a day. Costs nothing.

How it works

1

WhatsApp the deck, valuation, or screenshots — whatever you were sent.

2

Every figure gets checked against URA and HDB transaction records. Missing costs (ABSD, BSD, interest, agent fees) get added back in.

3

It comes back marked in red, with a one-paragraph bottom line. What you do with it is entirely yours.

Send my pitch for the red pen

Stays between us. Nothing you send is published, shared, or used to contact the other agent.

What the red pen catches — recreated from real cases

"Comparable units in the development have sold for $2,350 psf…" ↑ one penthouse, 14 months ago. The last six sales in this stack averaged $2,080 psf. Comps should be same stack, recent, similar floor.

Exhibit A — the flattering comparable. The single most common markup we make.

"Projected profit after 4 years: $180,000" ↑ before BSD ($44,600), interest paid (~$96,000), and selling costs (~$28,000). Rewritten with all costs: ~$11,000 — on a S$1.5M commitment.

Exhibit B — the profit line that forgot the costs. Always ask what's been left out.

"Rental demand in this area is extremely strong, ensuring your unit is always tenanted." ↑ no number, and "ensuring" is a promise nobody can make. The checkable version: median days-to-rent for this cluster and the current vacancy rate. Ask for both.

Exhibit C — the adjective doing a number's job. If there's no figure, that's the finding.

Benjamin Tan

Benjamin Tan · CTB Realty

CEA-registered. I mark the math, not the agent — most pitches check out fine, and when they do I say so. What you're buying with one message is certainty either way.

What comes back

Illustrative reply — yours addresses the actual document you send.

Fair questions

Will you contact the other agent?

Never. Your document stays between us, isn't stored beyond the review, and isn't used for anything except your markup.

What if the pitch is actually good?

Then the reply says so, plainly — it happens often. A clean bill of health from a second pair of eyes is worth as much as a catch.

Why would you do this free?

Because some people whose pitches don't survive the red pen come back when they're ready to move properly. The rest cost me twenty minutes and keep the market a little more honest. Both outcomes are fine.

Exhibits are anonymised recreations of patterns from real documents — no real project, agent, or client is depicted. The red pen checks numbers against public records; it's analysis, not financial advice, and not an accusation against anyone. Most pitches contain honest math — the point is knowing which kind you're holding.

Send my pitch — free →